Kirby and the Rainbow Curse Review – I Said Clay, What’s Goin’ On?

KIRBY IS MADE OUT OF CLAY!

01

Developer: HAL Laboratory
Publisher: Nintendo
Format: Wii U
Released: February 20, 2015
Copy provided by publisher

There seems to be no ends to the things Kirby can be. He’s been made of string, he’s been dozens of tiny versions of himself, he’s been a pinball, and he’s probably been some other things that I could tell you about if I did my research. In his latest adventure, Kirby and the Rainbow Curse, Nintendo’s beloved pink swallowgoblin has become a malleable construct of clay. It doesn’t matter why he is clay, he just is, and I’m perfectly okay with that because it turns out clay is a fantastic look.

So fantastic, in fact, that it’s a tragedy Rainbow Curse is almost unplayable if one chooses to look at the television screen. Controlled solely with the stylus, and requiring constant attention, this spiritual successor to Kirby: Canvas Curse requires both eyes focused on the GamePad’s touchscreen, which is a shame because the bright claymation-inspired visuals are gorgeous on an HDTV, showing up exactly how washed out and inferior the Wii U controller’s display truly is. Beautifully animated, full of subtle detail, and delightfully colorful, none of the game’s visual splendor carries over from the big screen to the little one, but you’ll be needing to keep your eyes down if you want to make any progress whatsoever.

02

For reasons unexplained, Kirby has lost the use of his feet and can only navigate the world by rolling around. The stylus aids our spherical glutton on his quest, used as it is to draw rainbow ropes in the air to which Kirby sticks. He’ll move in the direction the rope is drawn, allowing players to navigate him through the various chasms and traps by catching him, indirectly steering him, and occasionally blocking his path. Tapping directly on Kirby allows him to briefly surge forward in whatever direction he was rolling, allowing him to defeat enemies and get around with some extra momentum. That’s about all there is to controlling Kirby, but as with many spin-offs from HAL Laboratory, this one simple gimmick is built upon a dozen times over to create some impressively varied challenges.

Key to Rainbow Curse‘s success is the level design. Intricately built to get the most out of the central premise, each stage has its own little twist on the idea, whether it’s splitting Kirby in two and making the player quickly draw ropes in different areas to solve puzzles, using the stylus to guide missiles toward targets, or connecting pre-existing ropeways to form new paths for a gondola. There’s always some clever new way of interacting with the world, even though one’s input is fundamentally unchanged and deceptively uncomplicated.

At various points, Kirby will be transformed into a variety of vehicles – similar to his blasphemous mutant forms in Kirby’s Epic Yarn – with their own special properties. The tank moves on its own and fires shells wherever the player taps. The submarine moves where it’s told and automatically fires torpedoes that rainbow rope can guide. Meanwhile, the rocket surges forward and requires constant use of the rope to stay on track.

03

Collectible stars litter every stage, and collecting 100 of them allows Kirby to grow in size when the stylus is pressed onto him for a short while. Big-Ball Kirby can smash through otherwise impenetrable surfaces, take out large invincible enemies, and is often required to collect bonus points and optional treasure chests – the latter of which unlock clay figures and music tracks as little extras.

Of particular note are the boss battles, each of which are beautifully designed and require some deft drawing skills to avoid bombs, tentacles, and all other manner of aggressive interruptions. The first battle, for example, requires drawing paths around spiked growths to reach longtime nemesis Whispy Woods’ face and bash it in. It’s not overly complex, but it blends strategy and light puzzling in a delightful way. Every large-scale encounter has its own spin, whether you’re drawing ropes to block laser beams or leading Kirby around the rear of an opponent to smack it from behind. It’s just a shame that – not counting the final battle – the six major boss encounters are fought by only three bosses, each one appearing twice (albeit with an additional gimmick on the second skirmish).

For the most part, Rainbow Curse works brilliantly, taking its dozens of iterations on one fundamental premise and providing a good few hours of smart, adorable fun across both a story mode and a series of time challenge courses. Every now and then, however, the limitations of the screen-based gameplay can come into effect. A handful of faster-paced levels seem to outrun the general responsiveness and precision of the touchscreen, and the small size of the GamePad’s display can make the navigation of more complicated, time-sensitive areas more irritating than it perhaps ought to be. A few times I’ve found the stylus just doesn’t quite have the level of control I want, a hardware limitation that nonetheless impacts the experience with the software.

04

One disappointing facet of the production is its amiibo functionality. By scanning the Kirby, King Dedede, or Metaknight figures, players can bestow an added passive skill upon the sentient sphere, evolving his dash move to be more powerful and effective while also altering his physical appearance. Though it’s a neat idea, Kirby’s new ability disappears if the player dies once in a stage, and it lasts only until that stage is cleared regardless. Additionally, the amiibo in question cannot be used again for a day once scanned.

It’s the kind of needless, arbitrary, thoroughly Nintendo restriction that further hammers home a significant problem with a concept I otherwise really like – the rewards for using amiibo seem hardly worth the effort of pulling them down from a shelf. It’s not that I expect – or even want – amiibo to change the game in any dramatic fashion, but the restrictions on usage seem utterly pointless – and I still can’t believe I can only scan five of them in Hyrule Warriors a day.

Anyway, let’s not get started on amiibo, or we’ll be here all day.

05

The soundtrack is captivating, among my favorite musical scores in a long time (though one or two tracks sound oddly like they’d belong on a Wings album), and I cannot help but be thoroughly enchanted by the clay-flavored visual style during those few moments I get to look at the screen. From the bouncy animation to the various smudges and fingernail indents on the environment, it’s a stunning looking title with a most original artistic style.

Minor annoyances aside, Kirby and the Rainbow Curse continue’s Kirby’s hot streak of lovable, imaginative, joyful adventures. As shrewd as it is straightforward, HAL’s latest effort provides an afternoon of unassuming fun for a fair price, and no matter how much I try, I just can’t ever over how damn wondrous it looks!

8.5/10
Great

Joshua Trejo
Guest
Joshua Trejo

Great review jim. Did this game made you barf rainbows again.

Peregrin Frisk
Guest
Peregrin Frisk

Disappointed the subtitle wasn’t a Wings reference. 0/10 will not review again.

crusty inferno
Guest
crusty inferno

This game seems like it would play well or even better on a 3DS. Though having not played it my self maybe the touch screen would be to small I don’t know just looks like something perfect for it is all.

Silly Skeleton
Guest
Silly Skeleton

It’s too bad the Wii U can’t display a cursor or something on the TV screen when the Wii U’s pen is hovering above the gamepad. It seems like a really big mark against the game that you can’t comfortably play it on your HDTV.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

Since the touchescreen is not capacitive, that would be a little more difficult- but not impossible by any means. Since the only control you have is to draw, how about using one of the triggers to to “activate” the the cursor. You could have the stylus down at all times, showing a crosshair; but it wouldn’t start to lay down lines until you pulled the trigger.

Problem solved?

againelation
Guest
againelation

Does anyone else hear Jim’s voice as they read his reviews? Brilliant.

ElektroDragon
Guest
ElektroDragon

It’s a good game, I liked what I played in my rental copy, but I thought Captain Toad was more fun.

The problem in part is that you rarely can look at the TV, it forces your attention down to the Wii U Pad screen.

This game would make more sense as a 3DS exclusive.

Sanlumiere
Guest

Jim,

You were accused in one of these comments of having a Kirby “bias.”

Confirm or deny: Your home contains a shrine to the Kirby

The public deserves the truth!

Billy
Guest
Billy

If Jim can beg, borrow, or steal pink versions of his coat and gloves, then he should wear them to do a Jimquisition special video denouncing any Kirby bias.

ElektroDragon
Guest
ElektroDragon

Of course he as a Kirby bias! The bloke even looks like Kirby.

Billy
Guest
Billy

That was the point of wanting to see him wearing a pink version of his regular black outfit while denying a Kirby bias.

Sylocat
Guest

I wonder if the game is meant to be played with an audience, like, you can’t look at the TV, so if you have a family member who thinks it looks cute but isn’t into video games, they can basically watch a live-action Let’s Play.

HeSaNaEt
Guest
HeSaNaEt

Gaming for an audience sounds like it’s on track. I remember Miyamoto talking about making games that are just as fun to watch as to play. My family loves to watch each other play games, especially if we’re able to easily drop-in/drop-out.

ThatDeltaVthough
Guest
ThatDeltaVthough

So….Can I eat Kirby now? That pink blob looks so delicious.

Wellsy487
Guest
Wellsy487

I do love the look of the game. Sadly I can’t afford a wii u yet, and can only hope that the ps4 will bring a few more colourful games out. I know there are a few but the big ones are the same dark depressing sludge from last gen. Not saying they are bad games, but it would be nice to see a few more colourful ones out there.

Gendreavus
Guest
Gendreavus

The description of the bosses reminds me of Metroid Prime: Hunters. Are the bosses varied better than they are in Hunters? The point isn’t exactly a deal breaker/maker, I’m just curious.

kimiyoribaka
Guest
kimiyoribaka

How many times does Kirby need to beat up that poor tree?

(referring to the first screen shot, and how it appears to be the same boss battle from dream land, dream land 2, adventure…)

T8B
Guest
T8B

I DEMAND that Big-Ball Kirby becomes a thing immediately. Get on it Internet

ZippyDSMlee
Guest

Am I the only one that wants a true sequel to Kirby’s Dream Land and not an odd knock off,party or gimmick game?(hell still waiting on a great 3D Mario game….)

Deku baba
Guest
Deku baba

Kirby Triple Deluxe for the Nintendo 3DS

LaurenWiiU
Guest
LaurenWiiU

See: Kirby’s Triple Deluxe
No one ever talks about it, but it’s exactly what you’re looking for,
On the Mario front, play Galaxy 1 and 2, they’re as great and amazing as Mario 64 was for many. Also, Super Mario 3D Land is pretty amazing as well, though not exactly what you asked, worth trying something slightly different.

ZippyDSMlee
Guest
Can a 3DS output to a TV like the PSP could? No? then I won’t bother I’d rather wait on a emulator so I do not hurt myself squinting at a small screen and fumbling with small physical controls… I barely liked sunshine it tried to hard to get away from the power ups I loved, Mario 64 did that as well which drove me nuts, the only power up to have a time out the star… Galaxy…well…… I really hate the mini planet thing … I really want a Mario game like a combination of SMB2,SMB3 and SMBW, the… Read more »
ZippyDSMlee
Guest

All that in 3D that is with a camera that dose not drive me crazier than I already am. 😛

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

Unless you literally have some form of giantism that makes your hands too large for the 3DS and seriously affects your eyesight (because that is actually a thing), you’re just complaining to complain. Please stop.

ZippyDSMlee
Guest
I’ve had a DSXL and a used 3DSXL for a bit it just hurts to much, I like to relax in my chair with my big screen and full 2.1 stereo sound. I could do that on a PSP a Vita and 3DS not so much…. Gamepads I can lay the controller in hand on the desk or my big fat belly portables not so much since I like to see what I am doing and stuff. Hell the WII at times is hard to play since I have a odd setup and my desk gets in the way unless… Read more »
Tanneseph
Guest
Tanneseph
I had seriously assumed that it was a 3DS game when I saw a video with the game in action. It just makes more sense (in my mind) for it to be on a portable, given the mechanics. As it stands, though, it’s a great reminder to me that I just don’t “get” the Wii U – and I really want to! If I’m going to play a console game, I want to luxuriate in seeing my game on the big screen. That’s what the console gives that my PC and 3DS do not. I don’t understand how the Wii… Read more »
Snowskeeper
Guest
Snowskeeper

They wanted to innovate again after the Wii, and unfortunately they spent all their money on a second screen. I love Nintendo, but if the Wii-U ‘wins’ this generation of console, it’ll be because of its games, not because of the Gamepad.

Holythirteen
Guest
Holythirteen

He was also a golf ball! Sort of…

Jason Guarnieri
Guest
Jason Guarnieri

Kirby Kirby Kirby
That’s the name you should know.
Kirby Kirby Kirby
He’s the star of the show.

Kirbys
Guest
Kirbys

He’s more than you think
He’s got maximum pink
Kirby Kirby Kirby’s the one!

squirrel_killer
Guest
squirrel_killer

He’s coming riiight back at ya.
He’s coming riiight back at ya.
Give it all that you’ve got
take your very best shot
He’ll send it right back at ya for sure, yeah!

Sam
Guest
Sam

This is why I love the Internet.

Kirbys
Guest
Kirbys

How can I help you King DeDeDe?
I need a monster to clobber that there Kirby!
Well that’s what we do best here at NME.
You better get it with a money back guarentee!

*awesome saxophone solo ensues*

Kirbys
Guest
Kirbys
As an adult I kind of wished three other new bosses were there other than a reskin with slightly different challenges. But I guess that comes with the problem that they might’ve focused so much on every background and few things that they didn’t care so much with the bosses because they had to make it look so nice for kids and adults. Which says a lot of how much HAL cared but accidentally showed some laziness in not only the bosses but the themes too which are just a reskin aswell. It’s kind of interesting you left out the… Read more »
Kirbys
Guest
Kirbys

*forgot to mention too that the game alters a bit if you are playing with a friend as those hands in the game will try to grab Kirby and friends XD.

ATBro
Guest
ATBro
The Nintendo Blind Spot is in full effect around this game! I just can’t get excited about this game. I played it with my for a while and, goddamn what a mediocre experience. The core mechanic of the game is never (at least with what I played) used for anything clever. You are basically just going around to designated spots on the screen… and that’s it. It looks really nice, but you can’t see it when you are playing because you HAVE to use the game pad screen that isn’t high res enough to do the look of the game… Read more »
Plutoburns
Guest
Plutoburns
See, I actually found the core mechanic to be used REALLY well. In the later levels at least. Early stuff was pretty basic, but later levels found some really interesting uses for the rope thing. Bucket levels were interesting, I would have LOVED more levels where you control 2 kirbys and the gravity reversal going on in the underwater levels was interesting. And the game is actually LOTS of fun with a friend (my buddy loved grabbing me and throwing me into walls). Only real complaints I had were the recycled bosses and the forced to look at gamepad thing.… Read more »
Andy
Guest
Andy
“…people are convinced that every game Nintendo makes is great,” Yes. Jim Sterling thinks every Nintendo game is great. Like the time he gave Mario Kart 7… what, a 5/10? Seriously, even though Jim has a Kirby bias (I wouldn’t say Nintendo at all), claiming that he only liked the game because he was blinded by the fact it was a Nintendo title…? It’s not even true of most Nintendo fans because most Nintendo fans I know are hypercritical of every new Legend of Zelda release. It’s become a kind of cycle of “oh, the new Zelda? That’s the worst… Read more »
Dave Dogge
Guest
Dave Dogge

Jim, you’re the only Kirby player I know of. Who or what is your typical Kirby player / fan ?

ldub
Guest
ldub

You act like clay is a bad thing. Clayfighter and Skullmonkeys would like a word with you.

Greg
Guest
Greg

I remember Nintendo Power running an absolutely fawning preview story about Clayfighter 63 1/2, and then it came out and nobody actually liked it very much and I guess it sold poorly enough to kill the series. A lesson I have carried with me to this day.

Chris
Guest
Awesome review, as usual. I have a thing for clay games – The Neverhood (especially), Clayfighter 63 1/2, and the lesser known Platypus (possibly my favorite scrolling shooter-type game ever). The graphics on Kirby & The Rainbow Curse look exceptional. Am I the only one who never quite understood Kirby games? Every few years I give one a chance, with high hopes. I’ve played some of the nes/ snes Kirby titles on emulators as well… I have yet to be hooked. I don’t quite understand what I’m meant to be doing, and the experience feels so arbitrary. For example, I… Read more »
Panelhopper
Guest

Look how happy Kirby is! He’s. Just. SO. HAPPY!

Sergio
Guest

Fantastic review, I don’t mind the limiting an amiibo once per day thing in Hyrule Warriors. However, it shouldn’t be 5 a day and similarly it shouldn’t be limited once per day for Kirby. Maybe once per stage per day or something to not make it a pay to win kind of thing. I think that’s kind of the reason the limit exists, they want to give a bonus to players but remind them that this isn’t a system that if you pay 14 dollars you’ll beat every game they release with ease.

Even Luck
Guest

Lego Kirby, anyone?