Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Review – Shell On Earth

The best Switch game to date.

Developer: Nintendo
Publisher: Nintendo
Format: Nintendo Switch
Released: April 28, 2017
Copy purchased

I regret not spending enough time with Mario Kart 8 when it was a Wii U title, but if getting to experience much of its content for the first time through Mario Kart 8 is to be my penance, I’ve earned myself the best punishment in the world.

Experiencing each track in Mario Kart 8 is a fresh delight, with even Nintendo’s reliance on nostalgia given a shot in the arm due to just how vibrant even the oldest of returning tracks is. This is to say nothing of Mario Kart 8‘s bespoke roadwork, presenting a set of all-new racetracks that make terrific use of varied gimmicks and evolving landscapes.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is, as one might expect, a rebranded version of the beloved Wii U release, polished and enhanced for the Nintendo Switch. Such improvements obviously include a visual overhaul with Deluxe taking advantage of the Switch’s ability to understand what high definition means in order to produce a far prettier alternative of an already artistically delightful production.

Under the hood, Nintendo has made a number of crucial tweaks. Various options and exploits have been balanced out and players now get to hold two items at once by default, keeping a second in reserve once they’ve deployed their first shell or dropped their bananas. As a result, double item boxes have made a reappearance too.

By drifting long enough, players can now initiate an Ultra Mini-Turbo, getting an even bigger boost from their turns, while a 200cc engine class has been included for players who love it when the A.I. pummels them with red shell after red shell and generally lets them know how terrible they are at racing games.

Most interesting are Smart Steering and Auto-Accelerate, two features included to give less skilled or experienced players a competitive edge. With these features engaged, players are given a little extra guidance to keep their vehicles on the road and don’t have to worry about fiddling with acceleration themselves.

The trade-off is that Smart Steering will force its players on certain tracks which often means they can’t access shortcuts. They’re also ineligible for Ultra Turbo-Boosts, which means that while they can get through even the Rainbowest of Roads with minimal slippage, they’re missing out on tricks available to experts.

It’s a nice way of maintaining balance while keeping newcomers happy. Perhaps the more “hardcore” fans will take umbrage with yet more “dumbing down” but those elitists can, quite frankly, lick a Switch card and shove it up their urethras.

Nintendo’s only mistake with these options is activating them by default. I was initially confused as to why the game occasionally wrested control away from me before I tinkered in the options and discovered Smart Steering accidentally. It’s a great feature, but one that needs more than a quiet implementation.

Battle Mode has been given a significant makeover with five balloons serving as health indicators instead of three as well as the chance to respawn upon defeat – albeit with a halved score. There are five battle modes, each revolving around the general idea of competitive head-to-head fights as opposed to being first across the finish line.

Not the main draw, but an always-welcome place to take a breather from the racetrack, and one that has been given several new battlefields upon which to fight.

Because Nintendo isn’t Activision, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe features all the downloadable content present for Mario Kart 8, allowing players to choose such racers as Link and Isabelle. Six all-new characters have joined the fray, including some old favorites. King Boo and Splatoon‘s Inklings put in an appearance besides Gold Mario and Bowser Jr.

Most importantly, however… Dry Bones is back! Dry Bones is finally back!

My favorite Mario Kart racer – sorely missing from several key installments – has finally been resurrected to make MK8 Deluxe not just the definitive version of Mario Kart 8, but the best Mario Kart game, period.

I’m not kidding about that, either. After quite notoriously voicing disappointment with an unexciting Mario Kart 7, the sheer amount of energy sparking from this eighth installment is palpable. I love how chaotic each race above 100cc feels, how easy it is to drop into multiplayer matches, and how many characters and tiny little gameplay features creep their way into the experience.

Plenty of unlocks are to be found by collecting coins during play, with a bunch of vehicle parts that let players customize their rides for both aesthetic and statistical alterations. A handful of brand new parts appear, chiefly the Splat Buggy and Inkstriker to give MK8 even more Splatoon love.

After struggling to enjoy many games with the Switch’s Joycons, I’m delighted to report that Mario Kart 8 Deluxe feels great to play not just with a Pro Controller, but as a portable game too. I’ve found myself playing and performing satisfactorily both on the TV and in a handheld capacity, and I’d only give the TV choice an edge for how lovely it is seeing that game on a massive screen.

Unlike everything else I’ve played on the system so far, I’m finding even extended play sessions comfortable – and there have been a lot of extended play sessions.

Mario Kart 8, even pre-DLC, offered an exhaustive list of stuff to throw at players. Tons of characters and vehicles, over 30 (48 as of Deluxe) tracks, and an immense volume of gameplay customization options gave it more content than anyone in their right mind would know what to do with it, and while Deluxe doesn’t go all-out in offering additional loot, it’s certainly bumped up what was an already robust package.

One thing I wish was given more attention was the individual personalities of each racer. While some are a constant delight (the Shy Guy’s gibberish is adorable), characters like Wario and Waluigi are not as joyously cacophonous as they ought to be. Several characters who should be louder and more manic are significantly less so.

Perhaps some appreciate it for being less annoying, but I’m just not used to hearing some of my favorite Mario antagonists behaving with a modicum of restraint. Somebody please take Wario’s weed away.

Small griping aside, Deluxe is a beautiful and lively game full of stunning setpieces and shifting tracks. It’s a game that showcases Nintendo at its best – blending nostalgic callbacks with fresh content to craft an experience both familiar and exciting.

Both as a handheld and a home TV game, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is an addictive and important addition to the Nintendo Switch, one I’ve been struggling to stop playing once I fire it up.

I say this without hyperbole and not as a stealth insult to anything else – I quite genuinely believe this to be the finest addition to the Switch’s library so far. I can’t argue with how much I’ve been playing it and how much I want to keep playing it, even as I type this. It’s exactly this kind of compulsive experience the Switch needed, and if that had to be the result of a remaster, so be it.

It’s a damn fine remaster of a truly magnificent game.

It has Dry Bones in it, or haven’t you heard?

9/10
Superb

Cinebeast
Guest

I’m glad it’s cool. I’ve been watching Vinesauce play it and he’s been having a good time too — in between all the salt, of course.

I’m not really a racing guy, though, so I’m still playing Zelda. I ended up shelling out $600 for the damn thing, so I’m going to squeeze every second of joy I possibly can out of it.

Viggo
Guest
Viggo

“The best Switch game to date.”
Uh oh 😲

alverant
Guest
alverant

Oh no! A 9 out of 10! Prepare for a DOS attack for saying it’s not perfect!

InfamousDS
Guest
InfamousDS

I don’t like racing. Maybe Mario Odyssey will be the incentive to punch a 5 year old in the face and steal their Switch.

Before they pay for it at the counter of course. I’m not a monster.

Terriosaurus Hex
Guest
Terriosaurus Hex

Dry Bones looks seriously fucking metal in that screenshot there.
*Sigh* I miss Mario kart. And friends.

Jacob Campbell
Guest
Jacob Campbell

“they can lick a switch card and shove it up their urethra”

Pure Jim Sterling gold!

deiseach
Guest
deiseach

Hmmmm. My son is hopelessly in love with Mario Kart Wii and this review might be exactly the excuse I need to get a Switch for me. For him. I meant for him.

Andreas Dellrud
Guest
Andreas Dellrud

I did, it’s recommended. Double birthday present, mine was that I got to buy it and he got Mario Kart.

Andreas Dellrud
Guest
Andreas Dellrud

Liked the one game I got to play yesterday. Frankly I wish not everything, except a character or two and the car parts, was unlocked from the getgo since I think it gives the game a sense of progression.

MechaSlinky
Guest

I’m totally on the fence when it comes to things like unlockables. On the one hand, I agree with what you said. But on the other hand, it really fucking sucks when you want to jump into multiplayer and are limited because you didn’t play enough single-player. Maybe the solution is to have everything unlocked in multiplayer but not in single-player?

Andreas Dellrud
Guest
Andreas Dellrud

Or find a good balance between enough unlocked content and locked. There are a few characters that are fairly similar, I honestly don’t know the names of all of them, these could be locked away.

Alternatively just make the unlock threshold low enough to not become tedious or unlockable in multiplayer.

MechaSlinky
Guest

That helps too.

Christopher Hammond
Guest
Christopher Hammond

It’s a difficult problem for them ’cause quite a few people who buy it will have already unlocked everything in the Wii U version. I’m in that boat and I thank Christ I don’t have to do it all again.

Polishfury5000
Guest
Polishfury5000

Dry Bones was my go to character for that DS Mario Kart, that’s honestly a selling point to me. Always liked playing as a koopa racer (loved doubling up with them in Double Dash).

This sounds like the killer app I’ve been waiting for to get invested in a switch. New Zelda seems fine, but there are plenty of games in the same vein to scratch my action/puzzle dungeon itch. There’s​ not much that can do arcadey racing better than a good Mario Kart. It sounds like a much better party game than “1,2, Switch”.

Christopher Hammond
Guest
Christopher Hammond

Me too. I was seriously pissed that he wasn’t in MK 8, so happy now.

Jiryn
Guest
Jiryn

Loving it so far, totally agree with you assessment.

Taylor
Guest
Taylor

Dry Bones is back?!??!?! THE HYPE

Scaper
Guest
Scaper

I’m between buying a Switch and getting a 2DS XL (since my old 3DS is garbage and I need a new one). I have the money to get a 2DS XL when it comes out but I could get a Switch if I save up. I would have decided on 2DS, except… this game tho. What do…

Michael Docis
Guest
Michael Docis

If it’s just the condition of your 3DS that’s an issue, I have a 3DS that I bought back in 2014 solely to play “A Link Between Worlds” and am looking to part ways with. Let me know if you’d like it for what I assume would be cheaper than average.

Scaper
Guest
Scaper

Well, I say that I can afford a 2DSXL because I have over $100 in gamestop giftcards. (my parents prefer buying me gift cards for christmas.) And also for the fact that I would like to try gaming on one of the XL handhelds. Other than that, I don’t really have much actual money to spend. Broke college student, and all that.

GodzillaGuy92
Guest
GodzillaGuy92

But Jim, every single game ever released starts at 10/10 by default, and you didn’t list enough criticisms to dock a point from that based on the detailed criteria provided by the octopus that lives inside my brain. HOW MUCH DID MICROSOFT PAY YOU?!

Jake
Guest
Jake

That was a lovely review. I really enjoy reading when you are clearly loving a game. Your giddiness just oozes from your words. You’re a good writer Mr. Sterling.

James LaValle
Guest
James LaValle

Right? I love it when jim writes positive reviews, because you can almost hear the excitement in his writing, going into extraneous detail about every little detail that fine tunes and propels all the positives of the game to the surface to provide a genuinely fun experience. It’s almost like he enjoys playing and talking about good games?

Paul Barnes
Guest
Paul Barnes
Great review here, I feel pretty much the same way even having invested in the Wii U version quite heavily I’m still finding new life here. One thing that took me by surprise is I notice that the sound assets seem to be coming through a lot clearer, or have had a lot of additions and work done on the audio side. It could be that the Wii U relied on using the gamepad speaker for certain sounds, but the overall presentation of the game is superbly slick with a wonderfully colourful aesthetic in full [email protected] I also noted the… Read more »
BAH!
Guest
BAH!

So Nintendo *is not* Activision? Phew! I’m glad we cleared that one up.

It’s good to see that MK8 has returned in fine form. I liked it a lot on the Wii U, but I really didn’t have anyone to play with. And let’s be honest, the CPU cheat like motherfuckers. But if I (or my brother) get a Switch, it’ll be much easier to have some friendly competition.

Rachel McVeigh
Guest
Rachel McVeigh
Got this on launch day primarily because I never bought a Wii U, I need somthing else to play on my Switch and it’s been years since I played a new MarioKart (I still have a gamecube plugged into my TV to play Double Dash) and it is brilliant. I had a group of people around to play over the weekend and the 4 player local co-op is a lot of fun. Great variety of characters already available to play and with four people playing additional carts & wheels unlock pretty quickly. I really like how the design of the… Read more »
BAH!
Guest
BAH!

Yeah, the stats aren’t particularly helpful. it’s not even easy to figure out what each one affects. The “grip” stat *seems* to change the delay between initiating a drift and gaining control? I think?

Rachel McVeigh
Guest
Rachel McVeigh

I thought that was handling? Speed, Acceleration & Weight are the only ones I’ve reliably worked out. And of course carts, bikes, trikes & quadbikes all handle differently anyway and each character type changes the handling.

It’s fun experimenting anyway cos the game is fun even with a poor cart set up, if more frustrating.

James LaValle
Guest
James LaValle

9/10? For a mario kart game? But I thought Jim HAAAAAAAAATES Nintendo because he’s a Sony /Microsoft/PC fanboy?

Ken Kenly
Guest
Ken Kenly

Jim, is it a good single player game? I dont have wifi on my commute

Artemiy
Guest
Artemiy

That’s a legitimately good question I’m also mildly interested it since I may buy Switch in the future.

Paul Barnes
Guest
Paul Barnes

50cc and 100cc races against CPU are a cakewalk, better to use these modes to learn the best racing lines and to practise drifting. 150cc, Mirror and especially 200cc are savage.

I brought it to work to play at lunch time but I think it’s a bit too rage inducing for the office 😀

I imagine Battle mode would work well but I haven’t tested it as I need to unlock Gold Mario 😀

There is always time trial where you can download the community and Nintendo ghosts and race against them offline too.

Jim Sterling
Guest

Pretty good, but like Barnes said, balancing for single-player is a bit disjointed. 50cc and 100cc are piss easy while 150cc is a *sudden* jump in difficulty. You can get used to it though, and 150cc tends to keep things interesting enough. I’ve had a blast playing against the AI to unlock stuff.

Mirror and 200c modes are really worth getting into when you’re more experienced. They’re fucking brutal, but they can be a laugh.

PIERS
Guest

IT’S NOT 10/10! THIS CLEARLY SHOWS THAT JIM IS BIASED AGAINST NINTENDO! I’M GOING TO RAGE ON LIKE THIS FOR ANOTHER SIX PARAGRAPHS ABOUT WHY JIM IS A BAD REVIEWER WHO SHOULDN’T PLAY VIDEO GAMES ANYMORE!

Miles Saintborough
Guest
Miles Saintborough

So, fanboy attack when?

Sean Steel
Guest
Sean Steel

Are you sure you spent enough time playing the battle mode?

How can you say that all of the battle mode modes revolve around popping balloons?

Barely any of them do. How does Shine Thief revolve around it? What about Coin Runners? What about Renegade Roundup? Not one of those has anything to do with balloons.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

All other battle modes pale in comparison to balloon battle. It is, and has always been throughout all of history and time immemorial, the best battle mode.

Sean Steel
Guest
Sean Steel

That’s not even true. Polls among MK8D communities everywhere suggest that Renegade Roundup is by far the most popular battle mode.
Either way, preferring Balloon Battle doesn’t make the statement that all of the 5 game modes revolve around popping balloons any more true. It’s objectively false.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

Looks like someone is taking this shit way too seriously.

Sean Steel
Guest
Sean Steel

If you make a living out of writing game reviews, then the things you say in your reviews should be true. You can’t just flat out be wrong.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

Then tag Jim and let him know in a respectful way. Aka not your initial comment.

Artemiy
Guest
Artemiy

I mean, we all know this isn’t Jim’s fault. We know who should really be punished.
CHIIIIIIP!

Jim Sterling
Guest

The initial comment was respectful enough, and a fair one. I was more invested in racing than battling and provided shitty writing in that portion. I’ve made changes so it doesn’t sound as restricted a mode as I made it out to be.

Artemiy
Guest
Artemiy

So, 1.286 as good as Breath of the Wild? 😉

Mogster
Guest
Mogster

Spent quite a lot of time with the original so not sure I’ll pick this up, maybe if it goes cheap. Which it won’t.

Christian Neihart
Guest
Christian Neihart

Sweet! Been waiting to drop me dubloons on this!

1 2 3