Super Slam: POGS Battle Review – Pogs Are Not Back

Capitalist Pogs.

01

Developer: Playlab
Publisher: Playlab
Format: Android, iOS (reviewed)
Released: November 02, 2016
Freemium

It’s fitting that a 90s fad would find itself turned into a cynical, mobile free-to-play game. The 80s and 90s were full of miniature collectibles, often randomly sorted into packages with contents unknown to the customer.

It’s relatively common today – Magic the Gathering cards and “blind box” toys still proudly wave the flag – but the era that brought us Pokemon cards, Mini Boglins, and the Trash Bag Bunch is ripe for the picking, full of licenses that sit idle and ready for some two-bit game company to pick them up.

Enter Super Slam, a free-to-play game selling itself with the hashtag #PogsAreBack.

Let me tell you, immediately, that Pogs are not back, not if this sad little effort is anything to go by.

02

Super Slam: POGS Battle mixes the “free-to-wait” elements seen in such games as Dungeon Keeper Mobile with a collection conceit in which the purchase of premium currency is encouraged.

All the humdrum elements of a typical freemium game are in place – arbitrary wait times between gameplay that can be sped up by paying money or watching ads, a freely distributed in-game currency and a more important premium currency, minimal interactivity, and an obligatory disrespect for the source material.

Not that a mass-produced 90s craze merits that much respect, but y’know. A modicum of it would be nice.

To Super Slam‘s credit, this is not the worst free-to-wait game I’ve ever seen. The “solo” gameplay can be fairly regularly accessed, while one-on-one battles against online players are always available. This is nowhere near as atrocious as Final Fantasy: All the Bravest or the aforementioned DK Mobile, but it’s still just another unremarkable app out for a quick buck.

Gameplay, as one might expect, revolves around the originally intended use for Pogs – a use that never really translated well among the kids I knew as we found collecting them far more important than using them for any sort of game.

Pogs are stacked up on top of each other and a heavy “Slammer” is used to bash the stack. Any Pogs flipped over in the process become the property of the player who hit them. You use your finger to swipe said slammer into the stack, and let the game’s idea of physics do the rest.

It’s so obvious, one wonders why nobody jumped on this sooner.

03

In battle mode, two online players put a selection of their own randomized Pogs into the pile and play for keeps, taking turns to try and flip more than the other and win whatever they grab.

In Solo mode, a stack of pre-owned Pogs is built, and flipping them earns coins (the bullshit currency) which can be saved up to buy regular Pog packs. 250 coins also lets you randomly reshuffle your lineup of battle mode Pogs – it’s the only way to avoid losing your rare Pogs if they’re selected for a fight, because you never get to choose which ones are on the line.

The physics in this game are complete and utter bullshit, and gameplay overall is terribly implemented. Even though you can tap the Slammer to change its position and angle, there is only the illusion of tactical gameplay or optimal trajectories. There’s no good way to hit a stack of Pogs since you’re relying on pure chance.

I’ve seen unremarkable slams turn over the entire stack in one turn. I’ve seen slams impressive enough to warrant dramatic bullet-time turn up nothing. The Pogs themselves adhere to no known physical laws, but one thing becomes apparent immediately – battles are not tense, nor do they ever come down to the wire – they’re always won in a single turn.

That turn may come immediately or it could take several frustrating turns with each player sending Pogs scattering yet flipping nothing. It comes, however, always.

Someone will make the one slam that turns over more than half the pile and win the match. Oh, and the game doesn’t end when there’s a clear winner, it ends when every Pog is flipped. This can mean that even if one player’s lost in the first go, they’ll be forced to take turns trying, annoyingly, to flip a single Pog left on the ground.

The more Pogs in the stack, the better the chance of winning, so whoever gets selected to take the first turn automatically has the best shot of victory. It’s not guaranteed, because of again this game is pure chance, but it’s way more likely and reinforces the fact that luck is key in all things.

It’s certainly not fun whether you win or you lose. There’s no satisfaction in “beating” somebody because the game arbitrarily let some pretend cardboard discs turn in your favor. It’s certainly not enjoyable to lose and be stuck fighting over the handful of discs left, humiliatingly fighting over table scraps.

Solo mode gives you a limited number of slams that replenish in ten minute intervals. The idea is simply to flip Pogs and earn coins, with a bonus of 15 coins awarded every time you clear an entire stack. Theoretically you do this forever, getting the option to watch ads or pay money in exchange for extra slams.

04

While both modes could be effective timewasters and fun distractions, the fact slams are only ever wildly successful or frustratingly disappointing sucks all the interest out of it. Solo mode seems deliberately designed to drain your Slam counter too, with stacks almost always whittling themselves down to one or two Pogs that just don’t want to flip.

I’ve been able to waste at least 15 slams trying to flip a single Pog before, and that’s just not a good way to spend time.

The Pogs themselves cost 500 coins for a single regular pack, which can take quite a while to grind. Premium packs start at 9 “coupons” for a single one. In-game challenges can occasionally dish out coupons, and you get a single coupon per day for the first stack of Pogs cleared in solo mode, but the idea is of course to buy them.

Microtransactions begin at $2.99 for 10 coupons – enough to buy one pack of five Pogs – and end at $29.99 for 160. Coins and extra slams are also traded for real money too, if you really like this game.

You shouldn’t like this game.

05

One of the most appealing things about the original Pogs were their designs – these were essentially thick round trading cards that kids liked for their pictures of skulls and bodacious 90s colors. Super Slam is not endorsed by the World Pog Federation, the only authority I respect when it comes to Pogs, and its self-designed Pogs are atrocious.

First of all, they all share the same humdrum art style despite there being a large selection of themed sets. The desperately “wacky” designs are simplistic and fail to capture the 90s aesthetic they’re desperately attempting to ape. As a result, there’s no real joy to collecting them.

The rare “shiny” ones are barely distinguishable from the commons, and with several sets being based around such fun themes as bipolar disorder and overfed pets, the “edginess” of their artistic style is more than a little grasping.

Super Slam disappoints on a technical level as well. When played away from a wi-fi connection, it becomes supremely laggy and makes battles even more of a repetitive slog. Leaving the game even for a moment causes it to lose its online connection and reload, often taking the opportunity to reset the solo stack completely and undo one’s work.

Outside of the Pogs themselves, the overall aesthetic is tacky and sterile. The backdrop is a shittily drawn skate park, a shitty beat plays incessantly throughout, and a supremely shit voice over repeats phrases like “rad” and “crazy” when you flip Pogs, just to remind you how cool Super Slam cloyingly wishes it was.

07

A shoddy product all the way through, Super Slam is a sneering grab for ad revenue and microtransactions that weakly trades on nostalgia and brings nothing else to the table. Unappealing on its own and doubly distasteful to anybody who actually knows what Pogs are, it’s safe to say this is not the big Pog comeback it pretends to be.

I’d rather play with fucking Tazos, for God’s sake, and a diehard Pog expert like me should not be saying that.

2/10
Bad

fred hodder
Guest
fred hodder

I love the dissonance between those people’s profile pictures and Jim in his fucking Scarecrow mask

Paarthurnax1228
Guest
Paarthurnax1228

Contains Skeletons has got to be the best tag I have ever seen.

Jude
Guest
Jude

I’m from Mexico, here we only have Tazos :C

Weasel Biggs
Guest
Weasel Biggs

Whoa dude, gag me with a spoon! Gnarly review, man!

I’m sad Jim didn’t add the requisite tumescent whispers and growls while holding a fat stack of paper discs à la Long John Silver fondling Flint’s trove.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

That is an amazing description.

Weasel Biggs
Guest
Weasel Biggs

What can I say, the nineties looked like some boardroom committee had decided all of the world’s teenagers had a foot in California, thought Slayer and Megadeth were the bomb, and simultaneously liked Punk aesthetics.

I mean, as a Canady, my adolescence was spent as far and away from Beverly Hills and Encino as you could imagine. Considering, my own pogs’ orgy of palm trees and brightly-coloured Valleyspeak came across as Eldritch material.

YoDude
Guest
YoDude

For what it’s worth as an avowed metalhead I can freely admit some of those pog designs are brutal.

Sperium3000
Guest
Sperium3000

So not righteous, dude.

Benj
Guest
Benj

Is nothing sacred!

Weasel Biggs
Guest
Weasel Biggs

So long as Operation isn’t redone as a microtransaction-heavy affair, where a limited number of trials per game are baked in, I’m good.

Well, mostly. Seeing Pogs reduced to this is still fairly disappointing.

drez
Guest
drez

Extra points awarded for the use of ‘bodacious’.

Leon
Guest
Leon

Actually, for your information, Tazos could connect together like circular Lego and you could build towers and other stuff which you could not do with bog standard pogs, thank you very much.

Chris
Guest
Chris

…I think tazos were bigger in Australia than pogs were? Did tazos used to come with packets of chips? That’s what kids used to always trade in my school. Tazos, pokemon hologram thingies… these awesome trading cards I can’t remember the name on. Man… when did chips get so unfun?

Leon
Guest
Leon

Yeah, Tazos were in walkers crisps/chips. I got the whole collection of the star wars Tazos because kids at school would throw them in the trash as everyone thought Tazos were shit!

Whos laughing now?! This star wars collection is worth £8!!

Terriosaurus Hex
Guest
Terriosaurus Hex
Man, I used to have buckets of pogs at one point, the metal curly spiked slammers were the fucking bee’s metal knees! Turning them into digital non-existent monetised pictures takes away every positive about them. It’s not the same when the potential danger of a despised younger cousin choking on one hidden in their cereal is erased. It’s not the same when you can’t hold the weighty reflective metal in your scheming paws as you stroke it whispering “my shiiiiny…MIIINE!” AT LEAST YOU WERE PAYING FOR A REAL OBJECT (And in some cases; very tasty cereal). Damn…starting to feel materialistically… Read more »
squid spitt
Guest
squid spitt

Oh look! Something 4 the kids!!!!! Or the Big kids!!!! LOL

InfamousDS
Guest
InfamousDS

So, speaking of cynical cash grabs:
Some mobile developer is partnering with Square-Enix to make a “free-to-play mobile MMO set in the universe of FFXV and featuring cameos by its characters, setting, and references to plot elements”. Because why not? That’s all this fan base needs, a third goddamn mobile free-to-pay game.

I’m starting to regret supporting this game for 8 years, and I haven’t even played it yet.

darkmage0707077
Guest
darkmage0707077

Oh, and don’t forget that they’re bringing back the Square NES “classic” King’s Knight as part of the FF franchise. Because fans were absolutely clamoring for the return of THAT piece of garbage.

InfamousDS
Guest
InfamousDS

I did mention it, indirectly anyway, by saying this is the 3rd bullshit SE is trying to pull. But at least they can “justify” it by having it exist in-game as well.

This is just trading on the name while the iron is hot. I don’t know if they lack confidence or have too much of it.

Alexander Stallwitz
Guest
Alexander Stallwitz

Now i want to find my coffee can of Pogs and play. I loved Pogs and played it a lot in the 90s. I may not be a world class Pog expert like Jim but i played a few games.

SilentPony
Guest
SilentPony

I can’t help but feel there is a thinly veiled commentary on the Election here…

Anton
Guest
Anton

ITS JUST A GAME BRO

SilentPony
Guest
SilentPony

How DARE you! Voting is not just a game!

Jpkurihara
Guest
Jpkurihara

“I’d rather play with tazos”
Funnily enough the game refers to pogs as tazos in the portuguese translation.

eljueta
Guest
eljueta

That’s why I asked what the difference is, I only know tazos.

Anton
Guest
Anton

I’m sorry, a 90s “fad”?!? Pogs were LIFE

Max Whiteley
Guest
Max Whiteley
I’m going to guess that Jim grew up south of Birmingham judging by his southern accent. We used to call “slammers” “smashers” And pogs were used as currency in gambling competitions. There wernt that many kids who’s parents would buy them crap like pogs (mine included) so what we had to do is, somehow come into possession of a smasher and one paper pog. Then work our way up until you have either only your smasher left or a decent paper pog collection. It was all about the actual playing where I grew up, probably less than 100 miles away…..… Read more »
Polishfury5000
Guest
Polishfury5000
You know, if done right, a VR pog game could be pretty cool. Make it start out normal enough, fighting against the computer for their collection in fairly standard pog arenas (living room, school cafetria). But after the first few, start amping up the difficulty and absurdity of the arenas and stacks. Make it all about physics puzzles, forcing you to make trick shots to hit the stack. Maybe one boss could be an alien in a space ship with low gravity, or on another planet with higher gravity. Just go nuts with the physics puzzles, and I can see… Read more »
Eon264
Guest
Eon264

That… actually sounds like a lot of fun. I’d play it… you could probably do it without VR as well if one was so inclined.

Polishfury5000
Guest
Polishfury5000

You could do it without VR for sure. I just think the motion controls used with VR would be a lot more fun for throwing down pog slammers.

Eon264
Guest
Eon264

Yeah I agree, but considering how niche the audience would be I think making it available to everyone would be a good idea… why am I thinking about this like it’s a thing that’s actually happening?

TheMagicLemur
Guest
TheMagicLemur

Doing I can only surmise that this game was created solely to hurt you, Jim.

Jesse Helmfall
Guest
Jesse Helmfall

What’s the difference between Tazos and Pogs?

Mandrake42
Guest
Mandrake42

I never could figure that out. By the time though both came out I was in my 20’s so the whole craze was kind of bewildering to me. They looked like the same thing, but then, I was hardly the target demographic. I always got the impression they were either a rival version or a cheaper knock off.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

According to wikipedia, it looks like Tazos were the corporate “me too” for Pogs.

Kev' Bryant
Guest
Kev' Bryant

Tazo’s came free with Walkers’, like crisps (chips?) and Monster Munch (shaped corn snacks?). They also had notches around the edges so you could connect them together like Lego.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!
I’m gonna be honest, this reads like a joke review. Not that I don’t believe it’s a bad app/game, but the outrage I see here is borderline absurd. Now, we all like things, right? Many of us obsess over some thing or another to the point where it’s a big part of our lives. I understand all that, even though I don’t see the appeal of pogs. But as was pointed out in the review, pogs don’t deserve much respect to begin with. So a cash-grab app like this almost feels fitting to the philosophy of pogs and other “collect… Read more »
qorl123
Guest
qorl123

I see no outrage here, just distaste. “how does one even become a “diehard Pog expert”?” I think that was one of the joke bits of the review.

Andy McAwesome
Guest
Andy McAwesome

If pogs don’t deserve respect, it stands to reason that the game doesn’t deserve respect, either. Your comment doesn’t seem to contradict the overall sentiment that the app is a massive waste of time – are you just worried that the seemingly sincere devotion to the pogs brand makes Jim’s words come off as scorn, rather than critique?

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

Not so much, I’m just confused at the tone. There’s plenty of good critique, but intermingled with what looks like equal seriousness is some pretty absurd anger.

Usually, Jim’s tone is very clear. When he writes a “joke review” (eg. Senran Kagura) or uses hyperbole (eg. Star Fox Zero) it’s more than obvious. But this time, I guess my expectations got me confused.

Andy McAwesome
Guest
Andy McAwesome

This might be the point in which I reveal that I didn’t actually read the review, but lightly skimmed it. OOPS ALL BERRIES!

Jim Sterling
Guest

This was written no differently than my reviews of other cynical games, outside of the joke about being an expert and the World Pog Federation.

I think you’re conflating existing in-jokes with the tone of this review.

Also, reread my reviews of All The Bravest and DK Mobile. This review isn’t a patch on them.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

So I guess Poe’s law got me, then. Because like I said, there are people who genuinely obsess over shit like this, and even with the hints in place, it still sounds like something someone might actually say sincerely.

TheMagicLemur
Guest
TheMagicLemur

OP: I’m -not- trying to be an asshole whe I ask this, but are you autism-spectrum? I have a few friends who are and thet react to reviews like this the same way because they have trouble processing sardonic jokes and hyperbole. Again, not insulting you, it just seems like you don’t really understand Jim’s review style.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

Believe me, I’m not on the spectrum. And considering I’ve been reading his reviews since the site went up, I’d say I’m *pretty* familiar with his style. No offense taken, though.

TheMagicLemur
Guest
TheMagicLemur

You don’t seem to get it. You seem to think reviews should be serious buisness.

BAH!
Guest
BAH!

What makes you think that? I said it reads like a joke review – of which Jim has done several – thanks to the hyperbole. I simply wasn’t sure just how deep into Pogs Jim actually is, considering his apparent sincere love of boglins.

Because you know someone out there actually thinks they *are* a pog expert.

TheMagicLemur
Guest
TheMagicLemur

Ok, that’s fair enough. Also knowing that made me sad inside.

Stormbringer
Guest

FWIW I just read what you wrote as saying: but-but, weren’t Pogs the original freemium game?

Andy McAwesome
Guest
Andy McAwesome

I’m autistic and I understood the review just fine. I’m a little offended.

…a little.

TheMagicLemur
Guest
TheMagicLemur

Obviously it doesn’t apply to everyone. I asked because the people I know who are on the spectrum react similarly. I’m honestly just trying to understand this perspective.

I genuinely mean no disrespect.

Andy McAwesome
Guest
Andy McAwesome

No, I didn’t think you did. Which is why I say I’m only a little offended. Just a smidge! Just a teeny tiny bit. I don’t think ill of you at all! But thanks all the same for clarifying. 🙂

Batmatt
Guest
Batmatt

I’m sorry but honest question, what’s the difference between Pogs and Tazos? I think we only got Tazos on my country and always assumed it was the same thing with another name when you talked about it.

Sean Mullen
Guest
Sean Mullen

Tazos you could connect together through notches cut in the sides. POGS were just round.

Batmatt
Guest
Batmatt

But there were round Tazos too, like the Pokemon ones or the Simpsons ones… Usually they were round, but some series had notches so you could assemble them into some kind of shit or throw them into your little friends.

qorl123
Guest
qorl123

I think I might have only known tazos then, there were some star wars ones in crisps packets

eljueta
Guest
eljueta

so pogs are different from tazos?

SomeoneElse
Guest
SomeoneElse

Pogs are simple enough that they should be a good fit for mobile. Surprised that the way the freemium stuff is set up in the game, that they didn’t spring for actual licensed stuff.

SomeoneElse
Guest
SomeoneElse

So Alf’s not back in Pog form?

TheMagicLemur
Guest
TheMagicLemur

Then WHATS THE FUCKING POINT OF IT

Andy McAwesome
Guest
Andy McAwesome

Neither ALF nor Pogs are back.

Gareth
Guest
Gareth

Contender for the top ten list?

Adam Robert Sherman
Guest
Adam Robert Sherman

Took the words right out of my mouth.

Kev' Bryant
Guest
Kev' Bryant

Must’ve been while you were kissing me!